Pigfolio

The same pigment for less

Single-pigment tubes where a cheaper series or student line from the same maker uses the identical pigment, cheapest first.

What a tube costs depends mostly on the pigment in it, yet makers often sell one pigment at more than one price: in a student line and an artist line, or under two names in different series. Below, every single-pigment tube with a cheaper sibling from the same maker, cheapest first.

How the tubes are compared
  • Within one maker only. A series number is a price tier inside one line: Series 2 at one brand can cost more than Series 4 at another, so tubes are never compared across makers.
  • Student lines first. Winton, Van Gogh, Art Creation and Georgian cost less than the same maker's artist line, so they're listed first. After them, tubes run from the lowest series up.
  • Alkyd and water-mixable lines are placed roughly. Fast-drying alkyds (Griffin) and water-mixable oils (Artisan, Cobra) have their own series, so they're placed by series number only. Check current prices before choosing between them and an artist line.
  • Same pigment, same shade. One pigment can be made lighter or deeper, so tubes are matched by the shade in their names: a cadmium red light with a cadmium red light, a quinacridone rose with a rose, not a violet. Hue tubes are named after a different pigment, so they're matched with the plain version of the pigment they actually contain.
What can differ besides the price
  • Pigment load. Student paints often carry less pigment and more filler, so they tint more weakly and you may use more paint for the same color.
  • Grade and particle size. One code can cover several grades of the same chemical, which can change the shade, transparency or handling.
  • Binder and drying. Alkyd and water-mixable lines behave differently from traditional oil, even with the same pigment.
  • Lightfastness. Usually the same for the same pigment, but check each tube's rating; it's shown next to every tube below.

A quick way to compare two tubes: mix a pea-sized amount of each with the same amount of titanium white and look at the strength of the tints side by side.

What's left out

Earths (ochres, siennas, umbers and oxides) and metallics are left out: a single code such as PR101 Red Iron Oxide (Mars / Burnt Sienna) covers everything from opaque Indian red to transparent oxide, so a shared code says little about the paint. So are natural green earths, natural lapis lazuli, genuine rose madder and stack-process lead white, which share a code with a cheaper material made a different way. Lines that don't publish a series and have no student sibling here, such as Gamblin, Da Vinci and Vasari, have nothing to compare against, so they don't appear.

Every pigment with a cheaper option

PY3 Arylide (Hansa) Yellow 10G4 tubes

About PY3: Arylide.

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Lemon Yellow HueSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Winsor LemonSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Artisan Lemon YellowSeries 1 · LF I
  4. W&N Artists' Winsor LemonSeries 2 · LF I
PY74 Arylide Yellow 5GX3 tubes

About PY74: Arylide.

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Cadmium Yellow Pale HueSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Winsor YellowSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Artists' Winsor YellowSeries 2 · LF I
PY35 Cadmium Yellow15 tubes

About PY35: Cadmium zinc sulfide.

Royal Talens

  1. Van Gogh Cadmium Yellow LightSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. Rembrandt Cadmium Yellow LightSeries 4 · LF I

Royal Talens

  1. Van Gogh Cadmium Yellow MediumSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. Cobra Cadmium Yellow MediumLF I
  3. Rembrandt Cadmium Yellow MediumSeries 4 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Cadmium LemonSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Cadmium LemonSeries 2 · LF I
  3. W&N Artists' Cadmium LemonSeries 4 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Cadmium Yellow MediumSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Cadmium Yellow MediumSeries 2 · LF I
  3. W&N Artists' Cadmium YellowSeries 4 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Cadmium Yellow LightSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Cadmium Yellow LightSeries 2 · LF I
  3. W&N Artisan Cadmium Yellow LightSeries 2 · LF I
  4. W&N Artists' Cadmium Yellow PaleSeries 4 · LF I
PY65 Arylide Yellow RN3 tubes

About PY65: Arylide.

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Cadmium Yellow HueSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Artisan Cadmium Yellow HueSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Artists' Winsor Yellow DeepSeries 2 · LF I
PY110 Isoindolinone Yellow2 tubes

About PY110: Isoindolinone.

Royal Talens

  1. Van Gogh Indian YellowSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. Cobra Indian YellowLF I
PR188 Naphthol Red HF3S2 tubes

About PR188: Naphthol.

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Scarlet LakeSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Scarlet LakeSeries 1 · LF I
PR254 Pyrrole Red2 tubes

About PR254: Diketopyrrolopyrrole.

Royal Talens

  1. Van Gogh Permanent RedSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. Cobra Pyrrole RedLF I
PR108 Cadmium Red15 tubes

About PR108: Cadmium sulfoselenide.

Royal Talens

  1. Van Gogh Cadmium Red MediumSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. Cobra Cadmium Red MediumLF I
  3. Rembrandt Cadmium Red MediumSeries 4 · LF I

Royal Talens

  1. Van Gogh Cadmium Red DeepSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. Cobra Cadmium Red DeepLF I
  3. Rembrandt Cadmium Red DeepSeries 4 · LF I

Williamsburg

  1. Williamsburg Cadmium Red PurpleSeries 7 · LF I
  2. Williamsburg Cadmium PurpleSeries 8 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Cadmium Red MediumSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Cadmium Red MediumSeries 2 · LF I
  3. W&N Artisan Cadmium Red MediumSeries 2 · LF I
  4. W&N Artists' Cadmium RedSeries 4 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Cadmium Red LightSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Cadmium Red LightSeries 2 · LF I
  3. W&N Artisan Cadmium Red LightSeries 2 · LF I
PR112 Naphthol Red AS-D2 tubes

About PR112: Naphthol.

Art Spectrum

  1. Art Spectrum Spectrum RedSeries 1 · LF II
  2. Art Spectrum Naphthol RedSeries 3 · LF II
PR209 Quinacridone Red3 tubes

About PR209: Quinacridone.

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Permanent Geranium LakeSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Permanent Geranium LakeSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Artists' Quinacridone RedSeries 4 · LF I
PR177 Anthraquinone Red3 tubes

About PR177: Anthraquinone.

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Permanent Alizarin CrimsonSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Permanent Alizarin CrimsonSeries 2 · LF I
  3. W&N Artists' Permanent Alizarin CrimsonSeries 4 · LF I
PV19 Quinacridone Violet / Rose / Red6 tubes

About PV19: Quinacridone.

Royal Talens

  1. Van Gogh Quinacridone Rose (Primary)Series 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. Rembrandt Quinacridone RoseSeries 3 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Permanent RoseSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Artisan Permanent RoseSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Artists' Permanent RoseSeries 2 · LF I
  4. W&N Griffin Permanent RoseSeries 2 · LF I
PV23 Dioxazine Violet3 tubes

About PV23: Carbazole dioxazine.

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Dioxazine PurpleSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Dioxazine PurpleSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Artisan Dioxazine PurpleSeries 1 · LF I
PB29 Ultramarine Blue11 tubes

About PB29: Sodium aluminosilicate.

Art Spectrum

  1. Art Spectrum Ultramarine BlueSeries 1 · LF I
  2. Art Spectrum French UltramarineSeries 3 · LF I

Royal Talens

  1. Art Creation Cobalt Blue (Ultramarine)LF I · student grade
  2. Art Creation UltramarineLF I · student grade
  3. Van Gogh Cobalt Blue (Ultramarine)Series 1 · LF I · student grade
  4. Van Gogh UltramarineSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  5. Cobra UltramarineLF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton French UltramarineSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin French UltramarineSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Artisan French UltramarineSeries 1 · LF I
  4. W&N Artists' French UltramarineSeries 2 · LF I
PB15 Phthalo Blue11 tubes

About PB15: Copper phthalocyanine.

Blockx

  1. Blockx Primary BlueSeries 3 · LF I
  2. Blockx Blockx BlueSeries 4 · LF I

Old Holland

  1. Old Holland Blue LakeSeries B · LF I
  2. Old Holland Scheveningen BlueSeries B · LF I
  3. Old Holland Old Holland BlueSeries C · LF I

Royal Talens

  1. Art Creation Phthalo BlueLF I · student grade
  2. Van Gogh Phthalo BlueSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  3. Cobra Phthalo BlueLF I
  4. Rembrandt Manganese Blue PhthaloSeries 3 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Phthalo BlueSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Phthalo BlueSeries 1 · LF I
PB28 Cobalt Blue6 tubes

About PB28: Cobalt aluminate.

Royal Talens

  1. Van Gogh Cobalt BlueSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. Cobra Cobalt BlueLF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Cobalt BlueSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Artisan Cobalt BlueSeries 2 · LF I
  3. W&N Griffin Cobalt BlueSeries 3 · LF I
  4. W&N Artists' Cobalt BlueSeries 4 · LF I
PB27 Prussian Blue8 tubes

About PB27: Ferric ferrocyanide.

Royal Talens

  1. Art Creation Prussian BlueLF II · student grade
  2. Van Gogh Prussian BlueSeries 1 · LF II · student grade
  3. Cobra Prussian BlueLF I
  4. Rembrandt Prussian BlueSeries 2 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Prussian BlueSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Artists' Prussian BlueSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Griffin Prussian BlueSeries 1 · LF I
  4. W&N Artisan Prussian BlueSeries 1 · LF I
PB35 Cerulean Blue7 tubes

About PB35: Cobalt stannate.

Royal Talens

  1. Van Gogh Cerulean BlueSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. Cobra Cerulean BlueLF I
  3. Rembrandt Cerulean BlueSeries 5 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Cerulean BlueSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Cerulean BlueSeries 2 · LF I
  3. W&N Artisan Cerulean BlueSeries 2 · LF I
  4. W&N Artists' Cerulean BlueSeries 4 · LF I
PG7 Phthalo Green (blue shade)8 tubes

About PG7: Chlorinated copper phthalocyanine.

Holbein

  1. Holbein Viridian HueSeries A · LF I
  2. Holbein Phthalo GreenSeries B · LF I

Royal Talens

  1. Art Creation ViridianLF I · student grade
  2. Van Gogh Phthalo GreenSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  3. Cobra Phthalo GreenLF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Viridian HueSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Phthalo GreenSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Artists' Winsor GreenSeries 2 · LF I
PG17 Chromium Oxide Green6 tubes

About PG17: Chromium oxide.

Royal Talens

  1. Van Gogh Chromium Oxide GreenSeries 2 · LF I · student grade
  2. Cobra Chromium Oxide GreenLF I
  3. Rembrandt Chromium Oxide GreenSeries 3 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Oxide of ChromiumSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Griffin Oxide of ChromiumSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Artists' Oxide of ChromiumSeries 4 · LF I
PW4 Zinc White5 tubes

About PW4: Zinc oxide.

Royal Talens

  1. Art Creation Zinc White (Safflower Oil)LF I · student grade
  2. Van Gogh Zinc White (Safflower Oil)Series 1 · LF I · student grade
  3. Rembrandt Zinc White (Safflower Oil)Series 1 · LF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Zinc WhiteSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Artists' Zinc WhiteSeries 1 · LF I
PBk11 Mars Black (black iron oxide)2 tubes

About PBk11: Synthetic iron oxide.

Blockx

  1. Blockx Vine BlackSeries 1 · LF I
  2. Blockx Mars BlackSeries 2 · LF I
PBk9 Ivory / Bone Black7 tubes

About PBk9: Bone char.

Royal Talens

  1. Art Creation Ivory BlackLF I · student grade
  2. Van Gogh Ivory BlackSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  3. Cobra Ivory BlackLF I

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Ivory BlackSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Artists' Ivory BlackSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Griffin Ivory BlackSeries 1 · LF I
  4. W&N Artisan Ivory BlackSeries 1 · LF I
PBk6 Lamp Black4 tubes

About PBk6: Carbon black.

Winsor & Newton

  1. W&N Winton Lamp BlackSeries 1 · LF I · student grade
  2. W&N Artists' Lamp BlackSeries 1 · LF I
  3. W&N Griffin Lamp BlackSeries 1 · LF I
  4. W&N Artisan Lamp BlackSeries 1 · LF I

Data from each maker's published color chart, covering 24 lines. Check current prices before buying.

Open in Explore to filter, sort, compare and save them.